On a recent trip to Naples, Florida, I was again reminded that location is everything - well almost everything. It is clear that great food can’t cover up a bad location, but why doesn’t good food make it in a great location?

One of my favorite restaurants and watering holes in Naples is the Riverwalk Restaurant. The location is next to the somewhat famous Tin City and along a busy waterfront. Immediately next to the Riverwalk was another restaurant called Pier 41. The Riverwalk was always extremely busy; Pier 41 struggled for many years. They were within 20 feet of each other. Pier 41 was clean, had a reasonable menu and even had better access than Riverwalk. They never could quite be as popular.

On this trip I was pleased to see that a new restaurant with a completely re-juvenated concept had replaced Pier 41. Not only had I noticed, but it was clear from the wait at the door and full tables, the population of Naples had embraced this new concept. It was also apparent that the restaurant didn’t go through any extensive changes to the facility. Why did this new seafood concept work and the old seafood menu fail? I was determined to find out.

Before visiting the new restaurant called Pinchers, I talked with some of the long-term staff at Riverwalk to get their opinions and then ventured a few feet out of the Riverwalk and entered Pinchers. After a few minutes the differences were clear.

• The new restaurant had a more casual feel with staff in polo shirts and shorts. No more white shirts.
• The menu was pricey, but not unlike similar Naples waterfront restaurants. What the menu did have was an abundance of seafood items that neither the Riverwalk or the old concept had. They found a niche of local fresh items that tourists and locals would enjoy.
• The staff was well chosen and more outgoing. The old restaurant had a feel of competence, but lacked that enthusiasm of the new one.
• It was clear that Pinchers understood the demographics of their customer base than the old concept. Many customers went back and forth between the Riverwalk and Pinchers just during my time at the locations. The customers were portable and interchangeable!

The new restaurant had to go no further that 20 or 30 feet to figure out how to become successful. Look at the strengths a long time community favorite, the Riverwalk, capitalized on and re-invent them at Pinchers while offering menu alternatives. The old concept had a slightly more upscale approach to both atmosphere and menu. Apparently, people wanted less formality in a waterfront location. It was clear that atmosphere, menu and customer service will combine to make this new venture a success.

Location is critical, but you can’t forget the customer’s expectations - you have to meet them or exceed them in a robust competitive location.

Larry Edger, Author

The Restaurant Ebook